U.S. officers say that strikes carried out on three key Iranian nuclear websites have devastated its nuclear program, however unbiased specialists analyzing industrial satellite tv for pc imagery say the nation’s long-running nuclear enterprise is way from destroyed.
“On the finish of the day there are some actually necessary issues that have not been hit,” says Jeffrey Lewis, a professor on the Middlebury Institute of Worldwide Research at Monterey, who tracks Iran’s nuclear services. “If this ends right here, it is a actually incomplete strike.”
Specifically Lewis says the strike does not appear to have touched Iran’s shares of extremely enriched uranium.
“As we speak, it nonetheless has that materials and we nonetheless do not know the place it’s,” he says.
“I believe it’s a must to assume that vital quantities of this enriched uranium nonetheless exist, so this isn’t over by any means,” agrees David Albright, the president of the Institute for Science and Worldwide Safety, which has intently tracked Iran’s nuclear program for years.
The unbiased assessments stand in stark distinction to congratulatory statements from the Trump Administration within the wake of the strikes.
The U.S. army carried out its assault in opposition to Iran’s nuclear program early on Sunday, native time. Code-named “Operation Midnight Hammer,” the mission concerned seven B-2 Spirit bombers carrying large 30,000-pound bunker-buster bombs often called Large Ordinance Penetrators.
It seems that a dozen of the bombs had been used to strike Iran’s deeply buried enrichment website at Fordo. Two weapons had been additionally used to strike an underground centrifuge facility at Iran’s essential enrichment website in Natanz.
Concurrent with the bombings, a U.S. submarine launched greater than two dozen cruise missiles. These weapons hit buildings and tunnel entrances at a 3rd nuclear website at Isfahan.
A satellite tv for pc picture reveals broken buildings on the Isfahan nuclear website. The location was struck by cruise missiles launched from a U.S. submarine.
©2025 Maxar Applied sciences
disguise caption
toggle caption
©2025 Maxar Applied sciences
“Iran’s nuclear ambitions have been obliterated,” Secretary of Protection Pete Hegseth stated throughout a Pentagon press convention on Sunday. “The operation President Trump deliberate was daring and it was sensible.”
Each Lewis and Albright say that the strikes themselves might properly have been efficient, though it’s troublesome to say for positive. Satellite tv for pc imagery reveals six deep holes within the floor round Fordo, and ashy particles over a lot of the positioning. Albright believes that bunker-busters had been used to attempt to strike on the enrichment facility’s air flow system, together with the principle corridor the place uranium-enriching centrifuges had been stored.
“I believe the aim of the assault was to take out centrifuges and infrastructure and so they really feel they completed that,” Albright says.
However as proof that the strikes might have missed the uranium shares, each Albright and Lewis level to industrial satellite tv for pc imagery from the times earlier than the strike. The pictures present vehicles at two key websites — Isfahan and Fordo. The vehicles seem like sealing tunnels that function entrances to underground services used to retailer uranium, presumably in anticipation of an American assault.
A picture provided by the Middlebury Institute of Worldwide Research at Monterey reveals vehicles on the entrance of the Fordo enrichment facility the day earlier than a U.S. strike on the positioning. Specialists imagine Iran might have spirited away its provide of extremely enriched uranium upfront of the assaults.
Middlebury Institute of Worldwide Research at Monterey/Airbus House and Protection
disguise caption
toggle caption
Middlebury Institute of Worldwide Research at Monterey/Airbus House and Protection
Each specialists imagine Iranians might have additionally moved their enriched uranium out of the websites within the run-up to the U.S. strikes.
“There have been vehicles seen in imagery apparently hauling stuff away,” Albright says. “One would assume that any enriched uranium shares had been hauled away.”
The Worldwide Atomic Power Company had assessed that Iran has greater than 400 kilograms of 60% enriched uranium 235 — sufficient for round ten bombs, based on unbiased specialists. That 60% enriched uranium is carried in comparatively small containers that would match simply into vehicles, says Albright.
Though Albright believes this system has been considerably set again, he thinks it might nonetheless be reconstituted.
Albright says Iran may additionally have 1000’s of uranium-enriching centrifuges that had been by no means put in in Natanz and Fordo. It is likely to be attainable to maneuver the uranium to a different, covert facility, the place it could possibly be enriched to the required 90% for a nuclear weapon in a comparatively brief time period. Even then, Iran must take additional steps to trend the uranium right into a weapon.
“This system has been severely set again, however there’s a number of odds and ends,” Albright says. Finally he thinks the one technique to actually finish Iran’s nuclear program is thru further nuclear inspections by worldwide displays and cooperation from the Iranian regime, in all probability although some form of diplomatic settlement.
Lewis agrees: “Even essentially the most sensible bombing marketing campaign, in all probability is just not going to get us the place we wish to be,” he says.
